Court: ‘Baltic Foods’, which supplied unsafe poultry meat, breached the law
In December 2022, the State Food and Veterinary Service rightly ruled that “Baltic Foods”, a Vilnius-based company trading in meat and meat products, had committed an offence by placing salmonella-contaminated chicken on the market, the court has now ruled definitively.
On 18 November, the Supreme Administrative Court of Lithuania (LVAT) dismissed “Baltic Foods”’ and upheld the decision of the court of first instance from March last year, which had annulled the authority’s warning regarding the missed deadline. Nevertheless, the court still ruled that the company had committed an infringement by placing an unsafe product on the market, and therefore the warning was justified. This conclusion was also confirmed by the Supreme Administrative Court of Lithuania.
In its appeal to the Supreme Administrative Court of Lithuania, “Baltic Foods” requested that the court’s conclusion that the warning issued to the company was justified be set aside, and that the company be found not to have breached the Food Act.
“The court of first instance rightly found that, by placing an unsafe product on the market, the company had breached section (...) of the Food Act, and provided detailed grounds for this conclusion; therefore, there are no grounds to find it unfounded“, – states the final ruling of the Supreme Administrative Court of Lithuania.
Last March, the Regional Administrative Court upheld “Baltic Foods”’ and annulled what it deemed to be a well-founded decision by the Authority, ruling that the Authority had missed the deadline for imposing penalties.
The court ruled that the company had committed an infringement by placing unsafe frozen chicken fillets on the market.
“Baltic Foods” explained in court that it had not produced the fillets itself nor supplied them to shops – it had purchased them from a Hungarian manufacturer. Furthermore, it claimed that it had not breached any conditions regarding the transport and storage of the product, and that it had complied with the authority’s order to destroy all the products.
The company argued that it was objectively unable to prevent the unsafe product from being placed on the market.
At the time, the State Food and Veterinary Service (VMVT) stated that “Baltic Foods” was obliged to supply only safe food to the market and to assess its suppliers. Furthermore, according to the authority, the fact that the company destroyed the entire batch of unsafe produce (8,000 kilograms of poultry meat) does not in itself negate its liability.
The agency also noted that the company failed to notify it in a timely manner about the unsafe products and did not submit a corrective action plan. Furthermore, the breaches were repeated.
As reported by BNS, “Baltic Foods” has been fined on several occasions for products contaminated with salmonella – in 2021, it was fined 700 euros for 3.68 tonnes of contaminated chicken imported from Poland.
Furthermore, in January 2020, the company imported 3.9 tonnes of contaminated fillets from Hungary and 2.4 tonnes of contaminated chicken thighs from Romania into Lithuania. In June of the same year, the Authority issued infringement reports against „Baltic Foods“, but did not impose the €700 fine until December 2022.
This led to a dispute in court; in June 2023, it was ruled that “Baltic Foods” had been correctly, albeit belatedly, penalised for importing salmonella-contaminated poultry, and was therefore not obliged to pay the €700 fine.
Furthermore, in December 2019, the authority established that the company had imported 60 kilograms of contaminated poultry meat into Lithuania from Poland – at that time, the company was fined 300 euros.